Functional Movement Screenings
A functional movement screening can help you identify potential body weaknesses or imbalances so you can address issues before they become bigger problems. Learn more about the assessment in this discussion with certified sports performance scientist Todd Lewarchick, DPT.
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
Recent Episodes
Setting Your Training Table Menu
Ever wonder how college athletes fuel up to power their performance? Learn the nutritional secrets to their success in this podcast with spo…
Concussion Care 101
Recovering from a concussion is a process – and it’s important to follow it step by step to minimize damage. Learn more about treating sport…
Recovering From a Torn ACL
You feel that dreaded “pop” in your knee and instantly know that you’ve torn your ACL. So, what happens next and how long can you expect to…
Video content: This video is available to watch online.
View video online (https://cdnapisec.kaltura.com/p/2207941/sp/220794100/playManifest/entryId/1_tzh101wg/flavorId/1_5f3sgelj/format/url/protocol/https/a.mp4)
Co-Hosts
John Horton
Lauren Wichman, MDGuest Speaker
Todd Lewarchick, DPT
Transcript
John Horton:
Hey there and welcome to another episode of Sports Essentials, the fit sidekick of our Health Essentials Podcast. I'm John Horton, your co-host with Dr. Lauren Wichman. What you been up to, Doc?
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
John, I've just been really excited about this really interesting conversation that I think we're about to have today.
John Horton:
Oh, it is going to be fascinating, and we've been kind of buzzing about it since you brought it up. And what we're going to talk about is something called a functional movement screening. It's an assessment tool that's used to identify potential weaknesses or imbalances in your body. Basically, think of it as a proactive way to find potential issues before they become bigger problems.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Our guest today, Todd Lewarchick, is one of the best in the business to be able to walk us through what is involved here and how it applies to so many of our listeners, no matter what their activity or sport is.
John Horton:
Yeah. And it seems like, Dr. Wichman, the whole idea here is this is a protective screening, where you can learn how your body operates. Where there might be a little weakness or an inefficiency. And then you can kind of target your workout routine to address that.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Exactly, you hit it spot on. And we'll talk a little bit more in detail about what are all the nuances. But what it can really be beneficial for is being able to find some of those areas of dysfunction or asymmetry, what have you, to then customize an individual training program to decrease that potential risk of injury and potentially enhance performance.
Advertisement
John Horton:
Yeah. I mean, it's all about getting information, right?
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
No doubt about it.
John Horton:
So today we're going to learn how to get that information. So let's get to it. Hey, welcome to the Sports Essentials Podcast, Dr. Lewarchick. We've really been looking forward to this chat with you.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Thank you. I'm excited to be here. It's going to be fun.
John Horton:
It will be. But before we get into all that fun and our main topic, I got to hear more about what it means to be a certified performance and sports scientist. That's one of the cooler professional titles I've ever come across. It sounds like something that puts some serious brain power behind health and athletes level up.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Sure. Well, thank you. The easiest way I can explain what a certified performance sports scientist is, is that we like to look at what is involved in human performance from a very global picture. There's many parts and pieces that go into that. But specifically, we're looking at how a person moves, which requires mobility and stability and answering those questions. Is it a mobility problem or a stability problem?
We're looking at certain physical capacities such as power, strength, aerobic endurance, and so forth. And then we're looking at the demands of that person, whether they're sport demands, work demands, or life demands. And not just relying on one piece of the information, but looking at all that data and putting it together for that person or that athlete.
Advertisement
John Horton:
Really fascinating. And I know as we've done this podcast, you realize how the body is a really complex machine and getting all those parts synced up can be difficult, especially if you're an athlete and you're trying to maximize your performance.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
It's definitely not an easy task. And part of that whole thing is looking at that data, but also measuring what matters and then managing those metrics for sure.
John Horton:
Well, funny you should mention that because finding those little tidbits of information to help us make those assessments is kind of what you're doing with a functional movement screening, which is why you're with us today. I know Dr. Wichman had brought this topic to us because she's like, "It is such a great tool." And I know Dr. Wichman, you said you often send athletes to have this done.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Yes. It can be a really, really helpful tool when we're collaborating with our colleagues like Dr. Lewarchick in physical therapy to be able to not only treat specific injuries, but also figure out why do we think they even occurred in the first place and how can we prevent this from happening again?
John Horton:
Well, on that note, Dr. Lewarchick, can you walk us through what the main point of a functional movement screening is? And then we'll get into all the nitty-gritty details about what we do.
Advertisement
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Sure. Like any screen, right, it starts the conversation and doesn't end it. So really any screen will drive you to ask more questions. So what the functional movement screen is, is really looking at simple movement patterns and determining whether they're moving with a certain amount of competence. Are they moving with compensation, or within that movement screen, they're unable to complete the movement task? So we're answering those simple questions.
And then furthermore, we're looking at, is there a meaningful right to left difference? And if there is, ultimately that's going to raise those questions and go down a certain pathway, if you will, to find out why they're moving that certain way. So with any screen, it asks many questions, right, and then it will warrant further investigation to answer those questions.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
And picking up on things like compensation, asymmetry, dysfunction are huge because we see those being such a big piece of why injuries later down the line happen.
John Horton:
And I know from when I've been hurt sometimes, you'll have your ankle starts hurting or you start having some issues with it. And you go in and they're like, "All right, well, the problem's in your hip." And you're like, "Yeah, but my hip doesn't hurt." And they're like, "Yeah, but there's something in your hip that's causing your gait's off or something's going wrong and it's leading to the pain in your ankle." So it seems like this screening is a way to kind of root out the cause of a problem or an injury or some ache that's bothering you.
Advertisement
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
I think that's exactly right. So majority of musculoskeletal pain is really about movement. And so what is involved in movement, right? It gets complex quickly. But there's three major things that are involved in movement, and it's that mobility. All joints move. Certain joints are designed to move more than others, and some joints are designed more for stability. So what's involved in the movement process is part of the body needs to move, part of the body needs to stabilize, and then we need to control that.
I like to use the analogy of a car. So you can have a really good driver with a great engine and bad brakes. That's not a good recipe. Or you could have great brakes and a bad engine and a great driver. You need all of that. So the parts involve the mobility and the stability. But you also need that software part, which is the driver. So it's all of this kind of integration between parts, stability and mobility, and that human element of nervous system, right? Are you ready to move?
I like to say movement is a behavior. And with that being said, there's so many things that are involved in that behavioral process. Are you ready to move today, right? Are you recovered? How's your nervous system firing? So the analogy of the driver with the car, right, that the driver is really the nervous system. You need something driving that. But you also need good parts for mobility, and you need good parts for stability. That car needs to have a good suspension, a good engine, and a good driver.
Advertisement
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
And if you take your car into the mechanic, right, a lot of times, from somebody who sometimes doesn't know anything about cars, I take my car into the mechanic, and it's making a noise, right? And I take it there, and I want them to try to figure out why it's doing that. And that's where it is so helpful to be able to work collaboratively to figure out where do we think this is coming from? Like you said, is it mobility or is it a stability issue? Is it a compensation or a learned asymmetric pattern that has now become a consistent habit? All of those things come into this process.
John Horton:
Right. Well, to carry through with your car theme here, I guess the functional movement screening is kind of the equivalent of getting somebody up on the lift so we can look at everything and kind of test everything out. So let's go through the seven movement patterns that you look at. And I got to say, when I first looked at these, it's amazing how simple they are. And yet when you do this whole series of them, you glean a ton of information about how the body is moving and everything is working together.
So let's start with, I guess I got the list here, so we'll kind of run through it, throw it out there. And then Dr. Lewarchick, you can give us a little details on how it works and what it looks for.
And the first one would be a deep squat. What are you looking for with that? And what is it kind of testing on the body?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Sure. With the deep squat, it's actually you hold a towel or a stick over your head. And so we're looking at that relationship — number one, can they get that stick over their head and keep that head over their footprint? So they're standing with their feet, shoulder-width apart, with a stick over their head, and then we're asking them to squat. And ideally, what we're looking for is, can they get their hips below their knee crease? How do they do that? Can they keep their knees square or their knees caving in or caving out? Is that stick staying over their footprint? So in other words, are they hinging at their hips or leaning too far forward or back? It's usually forward. So we're looking at, number one, are they meeting certain movement requirements for each one of these screens, including a squat? And if they are, are they compensating or are they getting there with proper movement strategy?
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Whether it's somebody who's maybe had an injury or just doesn't really have the proper cuing, what are the common missteps you see with a deep squat?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah, I think a lot of it is, so again, with the screen, we're looking at just the how, and then if there's these deviations, we're going to break it down later to determine why they're moving the way. But often, three major things with that deep squat is either they don't have enough thoracic spine or what we call “the trunk mobility” to keep the stick upright. So they're hunched forward, so therefore, a stick will come forward. Or one or both of their hips won't allow movement, and so you'll see a shift.
So if my right hip is not moving as I descend into deep squat and my left is, I will always deviate toward the left side. Just like water will flow where it can, not where it cannot, same thing with movement. You will move where you can and not where you cannot. And then the same thing, just like the hip analogy, the ankles. If one ankle is stiff, just like one hip, you're not going to move there, so you're going to move on the other side. So what you'll see in the most common things is too much of a forward lean forward or a shift to the right or left, and that's often because of a hip or ankle.
John Horton:
And I take it you can see if you have muscle weaknesses or tightness, too. I know I am really bad at squatting. My kids laugh all the time. We do it. I can't keep my heels flat on the floor and I don't stretch enough or whatever. But I take it that's one of those things and you see where you've got things you need to work on just by how your body's doing the simple movement.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Correct. And that's one of the things we do look for, John, is that early heel raise, that will give us a ... especially if it happens early on versus later in the squat, that's very indicative, yeah, that ankle's tight. And then furthermore, we need to investigate that. Why is it tight, right? Is that a muscular tightness or is that a mobility tightness?
So when we say words like “mobility” versus “flexibility,” the mobility really implies how that joint's moving, bone on bone. Versus flexibility is that soft tissue, the muscular system, the fascial symptoms, the system. So there's ways to break that down because one problem will take you down a certain pathway and strategy to correct while another one takes it down a different. So we always want to make sure we're going down the right pathway for sure.
John Horton:
All right. Well, I'm going to tell you, first of all, I'd make a lot of noise when I do this, too, because everything on me is cracking and like crazy when I do it. But I want also, before we get too deep into this list, there's a scoring system that you use. So for each one of these you're going through, and as I understand, it's a really simple system. Is it a zero or a one to three scoring system, right?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah, good question. Yeah, it is a zero to three. A zero regardless of how you're moving, you could complete the test without compensation. But if it hurts, it's going to be a zero regardless. So you will see that it's rare, but sometimes you will see a person just being able to compensate correctly and the test looks great, but it hurts. So pain always drives us toward the medical world, and that's a red flag.
A one is inability to complete the test. And the two is where most people live, which is OK, being able to complete the test, each one of those seven tests that are involve the FMS screen, but with some compensation. And then a three is being able to complete each one of those tests without compensation cleanly, without pain.
John Horton:
All right. Well, so far I think I'm straddling the line between a one and a two with my squat, so I'll keep my score as we go on here. All right, so movement pattern two that you're looking at is something called the hurdle step. So walk us through that.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
So the hurdle step, well, it's basically a platform with two columns attached with a string. So the string serves as the hurdle, and we line that string up to just below the kneecap. So it varies the height based on the person's height. And so we're looking for, again, going back to that concept of one part of your body needs to stabilize while another part moves. So basically, they're standing behind that string on one leg, so it requires single-leg stance. They got to flex their hip up and over that string without touching it with their toe.
As they step up and over, they're going to tap their heel, pause and return without hitting the string again. And so you can see like, if you don't have good single-leg stance stability, your posture's going to change. You're not going to be able to step over that string or you're going to touch it. Which would be a zero or a one inability to complete the test. Or they're able to do that. They're able to step up and over that hurdle, that string, but they're swing their hip out or they do some type of deviation. They lean or compensate somehow to get that leg over the string, touch the ground and return, but it's with a lot of compensation.
So with that movement, what we're really looking for, can they do that with keeping their foot, knee and hip in alignment, vertical, up and over cleanly without touching the string and return with owning the movement without excessive effort? So that's the other thing I didn't bring up earlier is someone can do it, but you can see they're really, really exerting a lot of effort and it's not natural. Well, then that's not truly a three, that's two. So we should really be able to own each one of these movements.
John Horton:
And this sounds like another one that's kind of working or testing a lot of the lower body areas. Like your hips, your knees, ankles, that's kind of putting that to the test.
It seems like as we move through these, we kind of move up the body a little bit, which is our next one, we kind of tip up a little bit, which is the inline lunge. Kind of explain that one for us.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Sure. So far we've got the squat pattern and then we got the climbing pattern, if you will, with the hurdle step. And now we're looking at the lunge pattern, right, the stepping pattern. And each one of these moving outside of squat is going to involve a right-to-left determination. The squat's the only one that's looking at both right and left working together. So this gives us an opportunity to explore that symmetry, that right versus left.
But with the inline lunge, what we're doing is locking out the upper half. So we're putting one hand, we're holding onto the stick that we did with the overhead squat. But one hand's holding the stick here and the other hand's holding stick behind your body. So we're putting the upper body in opposition and the lower half is also in opposition, because one foot is forward while the other foot is back. And those feet are in line with each other. So again, it requires lower-body stability and upper-body mobility. And that we're looking at how they can do that lunge, lunging down and lunging up without losing control.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Are there any specific compensation patterns that you see with this one?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
I do. So what we're looking at primarily, number one, can they do it? But with the compensation, does that front heel lift up going back to the tight ankle thing with the squat? And often they can, but what's happening, interestingly, is that back foot. So they're unable, commonly, to keep that back foot in line with the front foot. So what you'll see is that back foot will start to toe out or toe in. And they lose stability because they're starting to move. And they either step off the platform, the board, or they're wiggling all over the place and they're not doing it with ownership.
John Horton:
I love how simple these tests are, but yet they seem to just give you so much information about how your body and all those muscles and joints and everything are working together to kind of get you where you need to go.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Correct. Yeah, each one of these, and again, when you see this, it just warrants that further investigation, right? We've got to be really careful not making assumptions. Because sometimes you'll see a lot of compensation with the inline lunge. But when you go to check out their shoulder mobility and their ankle mobility and hip mobility, it's all clean and very symmetrical. So then it comes back to like, OK, they had the capacity to do that. They had the capacity with mobility and flexibility. Why can't they do that, right? So it just goes down that pathway of trying to answering those questions.
John Horton:
Well, funny you should mention shoulder mobility because that is the next one. I love when you set me up for that one. So Dr. Lewarchick, what are we doing there? Obviously, you're looking at seeing how the wings are working and all that.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Sure. So it's kind of funny with sports science and the research, we developed some of these tools that have been kind of spot on in terms of reliability and validity. But with the shoulder mobility part of this, what we're looking for is go ahead and make a fist and cover up your thumbs on both hands. And then one arm's going to go up and over without creeping and crawling, the other hand's going to go up and back. And we're going to measure the distance exactly between the knuckles.
And what we find is that distance between a knuckle should be within one hand length from your wrist crease to tip of your middle finger. So that would be considered a three, that's optimal. And you may have that on one side, but when you switch, it's no longer a three, it could be a one. And with overhead athletes, sometimes you'll see that. And in a lot of cases, that's acceptable when there's a three to two difference, but ones are never acceptable.
So sometimes the goal is not to make that completely a three and a three. Certain populations, a three-two is good, but a three-one's never good. So a three is within one hand width, a two is within 1.5 hand widths, and a one is greater than 1.5 hand width. And that's kind of like the threshold where you don't want to be.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
I see a lot of patients that come in with shoulder pain and dysfunction, and posture plays a big deal. How do you see posture playing into this on your screen?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
100%. So the ability to have good postural integrity, number one, and number two, posture integrity under load is even more important with athletes. Sometimes, they may have good posture, but when you start loading the system, that falls apart. But specifically for shoulder, if you just raise your arm overhead with good posture, you'll have a certain good range of motion.
Well, if you start slouching and the head comes forward and the shoulders come forward, no longer do you have that same range of motion. So 100% it influences the biomechanics, the kinematics of the system. What's interesting, though, when you start loading the system, they may have good on their body weight, you start adding weight to it or demand or speed, everything changes.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Which we need for our athletes.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Correct. Yes.
John Horton:
Well, to get within one hand length, I think I'm going to need one of those giant foam fingers. That's about the only shot I've got, if you'll let me use that. All right, so we've been moving up the body here. Our next one, I feel like we're kind of going down a little bit or centering more on the core, but it's the active straight leg raise. What is that kind of movement and what does it test for?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah, from most people's standpoint, when you look at that test, it's looking, oh, they're just measuring hamstring flexibility, which in a way we are. Because again, flexibility is involved in how a person can move. But really looking at same concepts, right? Can one side move up a certain degree and we're looking at that criteria while the other leg doesn't move. So they're simply lying on their back, both legs need to stay straight. That means that there can't be any pelvic motion, knee motion, knee bending or toeing out or toeing in.
So when both legs stay straight and you're going to ask the person to raise that one leg up without the bottom leg, the lower leg moving at all. And then we're measuring that and there's a certain criteria we're looking at or a threshold if you will, can they get to that threshold? Yes. Are they doing it with compensation? Yes or no? Or can they not get to that threshold, which would be a one?
And so sometimes if inability to get to that threshold might come across as that they have a tight hamstring. But if you give them a chance to express their stability and there's ways to do that, all of a sudden now they're meeting that threshold, they're passing the test. So again, it's not that solution to that problem is not necessarily flexibility, it's a stability problem.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
And pelvic stability I see in my office all the time. I'll do a modified kind of version for this in the office with patients, and you really can see that pelvis, if the small glute muscles, like gluteus medium, gluteus minimums, have completely gone into hibernation mode, that pelvis just collapses when you isolate some of that movement. And definitely something I find myself wanting to send over to you guys to be able to work on.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah. Even going back to your postural question, that's basically the midline, right, is to center your mass. And so if you're already off in terms of pelvic alignment, that's definitely going to throw off how you move. And that comes into play for sure with the active straight-leg raise test. So we're always looking at, is the pelvis square? Are you in proper alignment to begin with? Because if you're not, that's going to be very hard to express and pass that test.
John Horton:
Yeah. As we've been talking through all these, I look at, as you're going through each one of these motions, I'm thinking about how I would do, and I know a lot of what you're talking about is you're working with young athletes. So if you have somebody older in there, are you grading on a curve when you look at some of this stuff? Where you don't expect the movement maybe to be quite as much. Or is it just good movement is good movement and that applies no matter your age?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah, that's a cool thing about science, generally speaking, sports science is these tests really fundamentally are needed for all humans regardless of age. So there is a modified version for someone at higher fall risk or post-surgical. We take away some of these tests to make it more prudent for that situation, but ideally all humans, regardless of age, should be able to pass these tests.
John Horton:
So you're telling me I'm not getting graded on a curve. That's what I'm hearing.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
No, correct. No.
John Horton:
All right.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
And the part of standardizing any test, right, instructions, how I give the instructions to you versus somebody else has to be the same or very, very similar. Because if they don't understand the instructions of the test or if I modified a test just a little bit, then I can't hang my hat on the results, right? So it's not personal. And that's what I say all the time, this is the way we standardize the test. It's done the same for everyone.
John Horton:
I'm getting worried as I'm looking at my scorecard here. Well, we're on movement six now, which is the trunk stability push-up. That seems like a core activity. What are you looking for there and what are you doing?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
These next two tests that we're going to talk about, the trunk stability push-up and the rotary stability test, they are testing the core, or AKA stability, but they're testing in two different manners. Going back to the car thing, it is that the trunk stability push-up is more of the car with a lot of horsepower, right? It's really you're testing your ability, do you have enough core strength to be able to connect your lower half with your upper half properly when you do a push-up from the floor up one time?
So how the test is involved is you're starting from the ground, and anytime you start from the ground, you're taking away what we call a stretch reflex. For instance, if I jumped off a box and jumped up and measured my vertical jump by doing that, my vertical jump's always going to be higher by doing that jumping off the box because I'm using a stretch reflex that's going to enhance that vertical jump versus not jumping off the box. I'm taking away that reflex and my jump height's not going to be as high.
So it's the same thing with a push-up. If I start from the ground and do a push-up, it's going to feel a little bit harder than if I start from the top and go down into a stretch and push up again. So the reason why we start from the ground is because it's more expressing the question, does this person have enough core power to length their lower half, their upper half? So number one, can they do it? Two, can they do it and how they do it? We're always answering that looking at the how. And so what you'll see with that push-up is they're doing it slow. They may start to rotate their pelvis, or they may start to arch their back, and they can complete the test, but it's not done properly.
So to get a three on that specific test, we're looking at can they start with their body completely straight like a board? And when they push up, that straight alignment stays. They go up like a board, they pause, they come back down like a board. Without excessive rotation, arching, or again, excessive effort. And what we see with those athletes, they may come across as strong and powerful and they are. But often the case, they cannot do that push-up. They could bench press over 300 pounds and squat 400 pounds, but when you get them on their stomach and to do that push-up, you see a lot of compensation.
So again, you never want to say they're weak because they're not. But for some reason, for some reason that comes down to the investigation process, is that they're not expressing enough core midline stability to be able to push their own body weight from the ground up. And so that's a problem. You wouldn't want that athlete to go to the gym and put that 400 pounds on their back and squat because they're not expressing enough stability today to be able to do that.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
There's a disconnect.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah. And then there's many reasons why someone would have that. Number one would be pain, right? Often your core turns off when they're in pain or injured. But it could come down to a hip mobility problem. It could come down to a pelvic alignment problem. It could come down to a fatigue problem, stress, poor night's sleep. There's so many factors They go into why somebody can't express that. But when you see that, the assumption always is that their core is weak. But oftentimes it's not. It's just there's a reason why their core today is not expressing enough power to be able to do that push-up test.
John Horton:
All right. And then you had mentioned rotary stability, too, which is the second half of that core stability thing. What are we doing with that one?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
So that's more of your Ferrari or Porsche, right? You're looking at a car that's not necessarily known for a lot of horsepower, but for a lot of agility, right? So we're still looking at the core, less from a standpoint of power, but more about control. So allowing them to rotate a little bit, but can they control that rotation?
So how that's tested is you use this board, the same board that we use, like the inline lunge test, and the hurdle step and the squat test. And what they're doing is they're surrounding the board with their hands, knees, and toes. So the board is touching their thumbs, the board is touching their knees, and the board is touching their toes. They're in this all-fours position, what we call the quadrant bed position.
And then we're asking them, one arm and one leg approximate each other. So can my hand and ankle touch and then straighten back out and touch again, while the other hand, foot and knee stays against the board? So it's kind of like doing a single-side or one-side bird dog. There's this common exercise where you're on your hands and knees called a bird dog, where my right arm reaches out while my left leg reaches out.
So it's a cross-body reach. It's similar to that, but it's the same side, my right arm and right leg extending out, coming together and then lowering. And once again, we're just looking at can the person do it, which requires stability on one side and mobility on the other side. And furthermore, we're looking for that right to left difference. Can one side do it or do it with compensation and the other side cannot do it?
And that stands to reason for all of these tests. We're always answering that question. Is there symmetry there? Well, number one, can they do it or not with or without compensation? And is one side performing differently than the other side?
John Horton:
And it sounds like, I know we had mentioned earlier, there's kind of a scoring. So obviously, 21 would be your max score.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah.
John Horton:
It sounds like most people, yeah, you laugh at that [inaudible 00:32:36] almost nobody gets threes. So it sounds like the total score is maybe you look at a little bit, but you're more looking at each one of these individual things because then those show you those areas of weakness that might need some attention.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Correct. There is what's considered overall composite score and lots of studies look at that and we're never diagnosing anyone with this screen. It just gives them information. But there appears with all the research that if you're below a total score of 14, that's not optimal. You're putting yourself at a certain risk profile than for someone that has a higher score, right?
So we're not saying that you're going to get injured. We're not predicting anything, but generally speaking, the lower the score is not optimal, the higher score it is. But I personally have never seen a 21. So what we would like to see is a score greater than 14, and no more than one asymmetry. The lower the score and the more asymmetries, the more red flags.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
And like you said, Dr. Lewarchick, I think even in some of our most elite athletes, it's probably not uncommon to not see that 21 when you would think, oh, they're at the tip-top of their game. They're going to be the ones that would be a 21. How could they not be a 21? But there are certain movement patterns that they have had to develop to be able to become elite at their sport, like throwing athletes and things like that.
And I think we'll talk about that here next. But I think that's a really important nuance where people might say, "How has he not seen a 21 in some of the really highest of high athletes?" And it's actually pretty common.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Right. 100%. And that's not a bad thing.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Right.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Right. So these are screens that are important, and we never hang your hat on one thing. But like, movement is a behavior, so everyone has their tendencies. So as long as we're keeping a certain number, ideally above 14, and we're keeping that symmetry fairly consistent, we start seeing more asymmetries pop up, then their movement behavior is changing. And that's where we need to have a deeper dive into the why that's changing. So these are baselines.
And it's always specifically with athletes, it's always great to have that certain baseline and to be able to go back and check that baseline and make sure we're either staying there, improving on it, definitely not regressing from it.
John Horton:
Well, you had mentioned the test itself, you described as the informational gathering stage. So now that we have all this information, we went through our test, which I think you said, I know we spent a long time talking through it. You said the test takes about 12 minutes. So it seems like it's pretty speedy. You see what you need to see rather quickly as you're looking. Now that we've got all this information, how are we using it?
And it seems like it can be very specific by sport, by activity, by athlete. Break down a little bit as to how you can use this information to help somebody, I guess, improve their performance or protect all their parts so that way they can stay on the field.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Great question. So exactly. I like how you said, “protect.” I think that's the first thing. So based on the information that the screen's given us, what should they not be doing, right? Going back to that trunk stability push-up, if they're working out right now and they're in a certain phase where it requires strengthening and they can't pass that push-up, there's one thing I would recommend to them and explain the why is, I don't want to load your spine heavily until you can express enough core power to meet that demand.
If you're failing rotary stability, there's no reason why an overhead athlete or even a runner should not pass rotary stability. Even running requires rotation. So there's certain things if you're not demonstrating proper movement competency on your body weight, simple task, then I'm going to ask them to do certain things or ask them to not do certain things until they can pass these basic tests.
Furthermore, if they can't pass it, then it's my job as a physical therapist working in conjunction with the doctors figure out that why. And that comes down to sometimes that's a mobility problem somewhere, a stability somewhere else. Or that could be just a movement strategy they developed because of a prior injury. They may have adequate mobility and stability, but they just learned to behave a certain way. They're starting to learn and strategize a certain way of movement, and we need to dive into just changing that. So I think the biggest thing is the protection and then the correction.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
I think that is a huge, huge important piece. Because I see a lot of young athletes who come into my office and have started a strength-training regimen with their team, and it ends up being kind of a team-wide thing. Everybody gets kind of thrown in and are told to do some of these heavy big Olympic-type lifts. And they may not necessarily have the skills or the individualized connection and safety to be able to do it, right?
And I think that's where looking at a screen like this and saying, "I don't think you're ready to jump to this because of this, this, and this." And then we can fix it from the beginning to transition them into weightlifting properly and safely is, I think, a really important topic for a lot of our listeners in terms of athletes and parents.
John Horton:
And how much of that is balance, too? Because it seems like when we're talking about this, Dr. Lewarchick, you had mentioned it's not that you're not strong. But I think sometimes you may get hyper-focused on doing one thing, so you really build that out. But while you're doing that, you're ignoring something else. And if those things aren't working at the same power level or same speed or however you want to frame it, it seems like you're apt to throw things off and you could then put yourself at risk for injury.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah. While we're working on something to correct, we're always removing something that ... as we're trying to protect them, there's ways around this to maintain a certain amount of their capacities, right? We can still keep them fairly strong without hurting them. It's just making sure that we're employing the right strategy to do that.
So to answer your questions, right, we don't want to take away things for too long to reduce their certain capacity in the areas while we're correcting on others. But we can't ignore that if we have to make some modifications in their current training ways. And often the case, it's just limited, right? It could be a few days, it could be a week, it could be one day, right? The reason behind why they're not performing today could really truly be a recovery thing, right? You need to recover another 24, 48 hours before you return to that. It could be as simple as that. It doesn't always have to be like, all right, we got to take three weeks off before you get back to loading your back squat or something like that.
John Horton:
Yeah. I wrote this down when we talked ahead of this. I mean, I think you said you're looking for three things. You want to protect, correct, develop. So you find the problem, you address it, and then you figure out then how to get everything working right.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Correct. And then once we develop that, we can further work on capacities to make it more resilient. In other words, to optimize and work on longevity and repeatability, and helping them stay on the field longer while we do a lot of that. Because when you set a certain baseline, right, that's within their own body and that's once you work on eliminating all the deficiencies or the dysfunctions rather, then we can look at deficiencies. Like how are you comparing to like individual?
And there's ways to do that. And if you're kind of falling behind the curve in terms of performing versus a like individual, we can improve on those capacities. But the first thing always, first from health, is how you as an individual is performing. Clean up those dysfunctions and then we can work on the deficiencies.
John Horton:
Dr. Wichman, I know you said you use this a lot with your athletes. Do you find with certain sports it really kind of pays off a little bit more? Or can it be used just about for anybody?
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Honestly, I think we see it most at some of our high-level team-based environments. So I think about some of our professional and our college teams, and these skill sets are used really, really regularly, as Dr. Lewarchick was saying, to build individualized programs. So whether it's pre-season, we'll do it a lot. Our athletes will go to different stations almost and run through some of these exercises to be able to realize, OK, so-and-so over the off season, their ankle tightened up. We need to make sure that we add in a little bit of ankle mobility to their individualized program. Whether it's like Dr. Lewarchick said, for a day, a week, a month, continuous, whatever that may be. It helps to guide how we approach their development and their management.
And we see it in a lot of different sports. The program and what we may be doing long-term to develop these skills will probably look a little bit different from one of our high-level baseball players to a runner. But a lot of the core competencies do remain the same.
John Horton:
And it seems like as we're going through all those movements and we're testing, it seems like it comes down to three big general areas that we look to address then. And that would be symmetry issues, which we all know right, left, there's usually one that's a little more dominant. Stability issues and mobility issues. And it sounds like with those three things, Dr. Lewarchick, you establish a workout plan or program to address any imbalances that might be in there to bring everything up to the level you want.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
100%. In most cases, not all, but in most cases, when you identify that problem and that strategy to focus on, initially they're not even aware of that. And nor have they ever been aware of it. Not always, but in most cases. So that awareness factor or lack of awareness is a risk factor by itself.
John Horton:
Well, because you're in shape, man. You're an athlete, you're whatever, you feel indestructible. And I wrote down one thing you told us when we met ahead of time, and you said you can't outfitness dysfunction. And I love that line because I think you look at all the work you put in and you feel so strong and everything. But if you have one thing that's out of whack, it kind of can leave you vulnerable.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
100%, because that comes back to that symmetry standpoint. And when you're operating at such a high level of functioning, you're not aware of that asymmetry and nature's not perfect, right? Look at a beautiful tree, the branches aren't completely symmetrical, but it's still beautiful. So we just know through science, there's certain thresholds. If you're within that, you're usually pretty good, right? Stuff does happen. We can never predict everything.
But if you're further away from that threshold, you're more at risk. And it's all about having a system that we routinely check in to that person, that athlete, to make sure you're within those thresholds. Because if you're starting to function beyond that and develop more asymmetries, then we're not managing the risk profile. And going back to that behavioral thing, everyone's different. So there are certain tendencies that a certain person, human athlete tends to develop, and those are things we really want to monitor throughout the season.
John Horton:
Yeah. And I love that movement is behavioral thing because we all see you adopt a certain gait or something like that. And if it's not quite fluid, you could be creating kind of a chain reaction that leads to an injury somewhere down that line. And it seems like this sort of screening helps identify where that weak spot might be so then you can get a workout routine or some exercises that kind of strengthen that one spot and then hopefully the entire system works the way it should.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Right. And if we don't do that, throwing fitness upon that dysfunction, or not creating a system to make them aware to self-manage that, and there's ways to teach them to do that. Adding more and more weight, or more and more power, or volume load is going to put them at a higher risk. So going back to you can't outfitness dysfunction. Number one, if they're not in pain and they're performing at a high level, the tendency is to just keep training or keep training harder. But at a certain point, if we don't identify those kind of dysfunctions and asymmetries, there's going to be a breakdown.
And that's why this is not a one-and-done thing. It's always having a system and it's like a feedback loop. So this is where you are today, this is your corrective strategy. We got you corrected, now we can work on performance. But while you're working on performance, we're going to routinely check in to make sure you're not drawing back to square one again.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
That routine check-in I am sure is hugely important. Because like you said, there are so many different factors that can weigh in as to why they aren't at their baseline. Whether it's, OK, we had a particularly hard training session a day or two ago, so we are a little bit sore. But checking in on that mobility before they end up doing that day's workout is critical to make sure that we're making sure that they can go do everything that we had planned for them in a safe manner. Or do we have to modify it slightly given what we're seeing on our screen?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Correct. Yeah. And there's so many variables that go into that. That state of readiness is really what we're talking about. So you can have a certain risk profile, but be ready. That's dangerous, right? But you could not be ready and have very little risk factors. You still need to be respectful of that lack of readiness for that day.
John Horton:
So Dr. Lewarchick, I have to ask this. I think most of us follow professional sports and we've all seen you have a high-level athlete, they're in shape, I mean, at top of their game, and you see them going down with these soft tissue injuries. They're a muscle pull. They pull a hammie, they do something like that. And you're like, "How do they do this? They're in such great shape." Is that maybe a pointer to these dysfunctions that you're talking about where they've built up so much muscle and so much power around them. But if you have one part that can't handle that, it breaks?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
I would agree with that. It's not an easy task to answer that question sometimes. But often they will have a certain tendency, and if that's not being managed or addressed, they continue to function at that high level, like you mentioned. There's just at more of a risk for something to break down soft tissue. A lot of soft tissue injuries will be a result of some type of asymmetry either at the core or some type of motor control issue where they're just not a certain pattern of movement. They're expressing that movement in not a well-coordinated fashion. And they're overloading their soft tissue in a certain way that puts them at that risk.
So some of these basic movements within FMS and other movement screens out there, too, can identify those strategies of movement. And make sure that they're moving a certain way that's competent, right? And if they start falling behind that threshold or that curve, and we're not identifying that, it often will tend to those kinds of soft tissue injuries, those hamstring injuries, those groin pulls and so forth.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
I always tell athletes that some injuries are out of our control, right? They just happen. They're luck of the draw, what have you. But if we can optimize the things that are in our control, we're setting ourself up for the best possible situation we can put ourselves in.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
100% agree. It's impossible to prevent all things, but what we try to do best is put that best optimal position.
John Horton:
Yeah.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Yes.
John Horton:
Minimize the risk going forward.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Minimize the risk. Yeah.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Right.
John Horton:
So if somebody's been listening to this and wondering, "Hey, I'd like to get one of these. How do I go about doing it?" What's the process? It sounds like it's not just something you go in and ask for. It usually comes as part of maybe a recovery plan or you're on a team, and it's done as a metric to measure things. But what can people do to get this screening done?
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Certainly. Well, the screening itself, you can look for certified professionals that are certified in the screening, but there's also people that know various different screenings, including the FMS that aren't necessarily certified. So there's definitely ways to search for certified-level providers. And with the FMS screen, you don't necessarily need to be a medical provider either.
Commonly, a lot of athletic trainers, and that's where a lot of trainers that oversee different sports teams, whether it's high school, college or pro, have some type of certification and movement screening, whether that's FMS or others. As a physical therapist, we're always working in the medical model, so we do see sometimes patients that are referred to us or not referred to us, but it's via direct access. But majority of our patients that we see are coming through the medical model from a physician referral, and often they get to that point because they're already hurt, right?
Pain has grabbed their attention to alert them to seek help. And they go to the doctor to seek help and then we get the referrals that way. So part of that process, part of that evaluation process is when often that screen's being done, because that gives us that information to... And what it does is it forces us to ask those questions, right? Is it a mobility problem, stability problem, motor control problem? Is it right versus left or is it both sides? And that puts us down a certain pathway from an investigation evaluation process to answer those questions.
And then that, furthermore, goes down that strategy, that pathway, so we can properly correct those dysfunctions. And then we can transition from that correction pathway to the performance pathway. And along that route, we're always communicating with the doctor and giving them updates, and if they're not progressing, then we refer back. So there's many ways to get the test done. You can search for certified level providers online, but often these trainers will more times than not have a certain baseline knowledge with these things, so you'll get it through that pathway.
We do see direct access referrals, and sometimes patients will be curious about their movement, so we just integrate it as part of their plan of care. And of course, physicians often will request it.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
As a sports med doc here, just like Dr. Lewarchick said, the communication piece is so key. If there's something that maybe I see on exam, but I'm not doing the full entire screen, but I think could be really beneficial, I always try to shoot them a quick message saying, "Hey, this is what I noticed. May be really helpful to include a functional movement screening here as part of your evaluation." And that line of communication is so helpful to not only give them a heads-up, but then they can report back to me what they're finding, especially if a patient, like Dr. Lewarchick said, isn't progressing.
John Horton:
Yeah. And it sounds like, I mean, this is the sort of thing somebody could ask for, too. Because it sounds like you gain a lot of information in this, and it can help you then as you're devising your workout plan going forward to really maybe target areas where you have a natural dysfunction or your body just... There's a natural kind of weakness built in and you can compensate for that by doing certain routines.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
100%. And even that protection, right, like New Year's resolutions, only a couple of months down the road, you know what that is? Most people want to get back to the gym. And that by itself, not exposing themselves to certain movement patterns under their body weight and underload and with higher volume is a risk factor by itself. And so what would be nice would be for that person before they put that action plan into action, is to get their movement screen first, to make sure, don't do this until this is corrected.
Because again, going back to if you add weight and volume to that dysfunctional pattern, they're putting themselves at risk. And then that full New Year's resolution is going to be pushed down the path because they're hurt. So the whole thing about this is correcting these simple things that often are not aware. And the correction doesn't necessarily have to take weeks or months, right? It could literally be way quicker than you think. But once we're corrected, then we can start working on that fitness and then move forward from there.
John Horton:
It really just gets into the whole science of movement and fitness and all that, which is kind of where we started. So I love when things kind of come full circle and bring us back there. As we're kind of wrapping things up here, just I'd like some final thoughts from both of you as far as how you see functional movement screenings fitting into somebody's plan and the value they can get out of them.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Sure. I think the future is bright for a lot of this kind of topic with the advent of technology. We're not going to escape that, right? A lot of these movement screenings now are developing to the public where you can do movement screens from your own home, right? So in other words, using your iPad or laptop your software, there's motion capture technology. They can look at certain movements like the FMS screen and others that will identify with high-level reliability now and validity, identifying that they're moving a certain way that should be corrected.
Either via corrective exercise given to them via that platform. Or if they're moving a certain way and they have pain to alert them to go seek help. Go see Dr. Wichman, go see me, right, go see someone. So where I see this going is taking advantage of this technology that's out there to do self-screens, and that self-screening will keep them healthy or alert them to go get help.
I also see this as something that the whole concept of self-screening and awareness or lack of awareness in the medical community, we can give them, it doesn't have to be high-tech stuff, but just some nuggets of information, some simple educational things to do. There's simple ways to screen your own ankle mobility, hip mobility, shoulder mobility. And if you're lacking, if you're behind that threshold I mentioned, here are some things to try without hurting them, without putting them at further risk.
So where I see this going is taking advantage of some technology that's out there from a self-screening standpoint. But we can make this low-tech, as well as just giving them simple strategies to do to check in with their own body and give them strategies to not only improve, but also just these self-screens. OK, I'm good. Green light, it's kind of like a stoplight.
Green light means go, continue. Yeah. Yellow light, some caution, maybe do this. And the red light is stop. OK, I need some help or if I'm going along this strategy to correct and it's not improving, that red light means I should go see Dr. Wichman or Todd or somebody else.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
I would say from my end, I think right now, we use it a lot with athletes that I know have some sort of overuse or overcompensation injury that we're trying to figure out why it even happened in the first place. Prime example being some of my young throwing athletes who come in with a Little League shoulder or a Little League elbow, irritation of those growth plates from throwing and throwing and throwing. And a lot of times I send them over to Dr. Lewarchick to be able to take a look at things like ankle and hip mobility, as well as trunk stabilization. Which, at first, the athletes are a little bit confused why they may be working on those things when they came in for their elbow. But those things are so important for that kinematic chain to not only heal them up, but prevent it from happening in the future.
And I think that that is a huge piece for going forward, that correct and develop. If we can continue to implement the tools that Dr. Lewarchick was talking about, to try to prevent people in the nicest way from having to come into my office in the first place, that would be the best-case scenario.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah, I agree. And getting to that buy-in, like what you mentioned, I think is really important, too. Because sometimes you start that process, it's going to, Whoa, whoa, I'm here for my elbow. I'm not here for my ankle. But putting all those pieces together to make sure they really understand the why and connecting those dots, then it's like, wow, now you're getting buy-in, right? They understand and it's cool because now they're looking at the entire body, not just the elbow.
And I find that it brings them energy and they're motivated by that. And it's not just this monotonous elbow treatment per se, which there's some of that that goes into it, but it's fun, right? It's engaging, it's meaningful, and it puts the entire problem into perspective.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
And meaningful, not just from the standpoint of, oh, we're going to try to prevent this injury going forward. But I've had guys come back in and they're really excited because they're increasing their VLO. And they're like, "Oh, wow, this is great." They get that reward process of throwing the ball faster because they're actually using their body in the right way, in addition to preventing future injury.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah, that is cool when that happens and that does happen a lot.
John Horton:
Yeah. It's amazing just when you get a little bit more understanding about how your body works, how you can really use that knowledge to boost your performance, protect against injury, and just really be the best athlete you can be.
Dr. Lewarchick, I really appreciate you coming in and kind of walking us through this. These tests, they're so simple and yet they give us so much information. And really like the way you kind of walked us through that. And hopefully, people can use this, take advantage of it and maybe get a screening done.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Yeah. I hope so, too. I'm here for you if it needs to be done for sure.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Thank you so much for coming. This was fantastic.
Dr. Todd Lewarchick:
Thank you. It was fun. Appreciate it.
John Horton:
So Dr. Wichman, I have to say, after listening to that whole thing we started, and you think, Oh, this is going to be these complex tests. And I was just amazed at how simple these movements are and yet how they tell us just so, so much.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Absolutely. I think these tests are not only a really good indicator, but they're something that we can all understand in a way. And realize how little subtleties in that movement can make a big difference.
John Horton:
They are just little things. And Dr. Lewarchick, as he was laying that out, you realize just subtle movements, and maybe you have a little bit of a weakness or the one side, but what that means as you're doing your workout routines or your activities over and over and over again, that can really take a toll on your body and eventually cause a breakdown.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
And one of the big takeaways that I think is important for our listeners is, this is something that is so universal, no matter what sport you play. There's no grading on a curve, as we had talked about.
John Horton:
No, I know. I'm a little bummed about that.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Right, right. But it's universal and can be so useful for so many different people that I think there's something that everybody can take away here and think about when they're going through their warm-up routine or going through a workout, or to be able to do a little self-assessment and recovery.
John Horton:
Yeah. And it sounds like this is one of those things you can ask for when you go in. There's some online tools it sounds like you can find and maybe do it, but there's a lot of just valuable information that you can get, which can just help you perform better, feel better, and hopefully avoid having to go in to deal with something that gets hurt.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Absolutely. I think it's going to vary based on system by system. But I think recommending to our listeners to bring it up to whoever you're training with, your athletic trainers or your physical therapist, to see what their knowledge base is, and how we can maybe add it to your individual assessment, I think is a really important piece.
John Horton:
Yeah. Well, I'm a little concerned about what my score is going to be, but it's always good to have things to work on.
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
Information, John. Information, not the scores necessarily.
John Horton:
I'm a competitive guy, but-
Dr. Lauren Wichman:
…I know.
John Horton:
Anyway, hey everyone, thank you for listening today. And if you liked what you heard, please hit the subscribe button and leave a comment to share your thoughts. Until next time, play hard and be well.
Recent Episodes
Setting Your Training Table Menu
Ever wonder how college athletes fuel up to power their performance? Learn the nutritional secrets to their success in this podcast with spo…
Concussion Care 101
Recovering from a concussion is a process – and it’s important to follow it step by step to minimize damage. Learn more about treating sport…
Recovering From a Torn ACL
You feel that dreaded “pop” in your knee and instantly know that you’ve torn your ACL. So, what happens next and how long can you expect to…
Never miss a moment - subscribe now.
Listen to the Sports Essentials Podcast on your favorite streaming platform.
Other Podcasts You May Love
Beyond Leadership
Hosts Jim Pae and Elizabeth Pugel escort you through a network of thought leaders, sharing world-cla…
Beyond the Pages: CCJM Podcast
Beyond the Pages: CCJM Podcast takes the listener more in-depth into Cleveland Clinic Journal of Med…
Butts & Guts
A Cleveland Clinic podcast exploring your digestive and surgical health from end to end. You’ll lear…
Cancer Advances
A Cleveland Clinic podcast for medical professionals exploring the latest innovative research and cl…