How ‘Set Point Theory’ Complicates Weight Loss
“Set point theory” is a concept that says your body has a preferred weight range and works to keep you there. It helps explain why weight loss can be so difficult. But your set point can be changed. Learn what it takes in this podcast with Dr. Peminda Cabandugama.
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
Recent Episodes
What Is Pulsed Electromagnetic Field (PEMF) Therapy?
Pulsed electromagnetic field (PEMF) therapy might sound space-age, but it’s a simple treatment that has become a popular option in wellness…
Do Our Eyes Grow as We Age?
It’s no secret we grow a lot between birth and adulthood – but do our eyes jump in size during that time, too? The answer is yes, with most…
Answering Questions About ADHD Medications
ADHD medications are widely used and often very effective – but they also come with questions. What do drugs like Ritalin and Adderall actua…
Video content: This video is available to watch online.
View video online (https://cdnapisec.kaltura.com/p/2207941/sp/220794100/playManifest/entryId/1_btvhqn2r/flavorId/1_5f3sgelj/format/url/protocol/https/a.mp4)
Host
John Horton
Guest Speaker
Transcript
John Horton:
Hello, and welcome to another Health Essentials Podcast. I'm John Horton, your host. Trying to lose weight can be incredibly frustrating, especially when it feels like your body is working against you. That conflict is the idea behind something called set point theory. It's a concept that says your body has a preferred weight range and works to keep you there. It helps explain why weight loss can be so difficult and why lost pounds often return.
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
But can you change your set point? It is possible, but it's not easy. We're going to talk through that difficult process today with endocrinologist and obesity medicine specialist, Peminda Cabandugama, who is also a fellow of the Obesity Society. Dr. C. is one of the many experts at Cleveland Clinic who pop into our weekly podcast to talk health. So with that in mind, let's find out why our bodies can be a little stubborn when it comes to weight loss and how we might be able to convince it to give in and move. Nice to see you again, Dr. C. As usual, we've got a weighty topic to chat about today.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Always happy to see you, John. Thanks again for having me on the podcast.
John Horton:
Well, we love... You're on our top-tier guest list.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
I'll take it.
John Horton:
Whenever you're on, we always seem to talk about weight and weight management and things like that. And it's no secret that losing weight can be extremely tough. Those pounds just never seem to melt off easily. And that struggle to shrink the number on our scale is explained in part by something called set point theory. Can you kind of walk us through what that is?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah, so that's a great point. So yeah, one of the reasons why we think that weight is such a hard problem to overcome, and why we tell people that weight management is treatment of a chronic disease, is the concept of set point, like you said. So set point is that, as our life kind of progresses, weight tends to usually go up with it. And the reason for that is... Yeah, exactly. So it's very multifactorial.
Advertisement
There's a slide I usually give in my lectures which shows how we thought about weight and how things have progressed to where it is now. Initially we just thought, OK, we're taking in too many calories and not burning it off. And then we learned that our brain is involved, there are hedonic pathways that are involved, there are stress responses involved. And then after that we started learning about all these molecules and peptides and hormones in our body that affects our weight. Again, that's just the basics of what we're talking about.
But all of them contribute to a set point that happens at different points in our life where our weight tends to go up, and then when we try interventions to drop the weight, we release a lot of these hormones, peptides, or the changes in our neural pathways in our brain, which tries to bring our weight back to what it was.
So the way I explain to my patients about set point is our weight is a set point, means each point of our life we get to a weight. And then when we try to lose weight, we release all these hormones and pathways that tries to bring our weight back up. However, when we gain weight, there isn't really that many hormones or peptides or neural pathways that tries to drop our weight down. Instead, we get things like diabetes and high blood pressure and all the other chronic conditions that go with weight.
Advertisement
So the set point theory is the fact that, as our life progresses, the weight tends to go up, and then it becomes recalcitrant or stubborn at that point. And that's why the whole concept of weight management then came up, and we are now finding these kind of interventions that hopefully helps to rearrange that set point with all the other modalities that we use.
John Horton:
So it sounds like the idea is then you have all these things going on in your body that control where your weight's at. And it sounds like then, within your system, like you said, you have hormones being released and things like that, that kind of control things like your hunger, how full you feel, your metabolism, even your energy levels. And all of that's used to keep you at this kind of set weight that your body's decided is where you need to be.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
That is correct. So that is the concept that is well known within our system called homeostasis. So when we get to homeostasis, or balance, that balance at different points of our life is different. So the other word for the set point is homeostasis at those places that your body tries to keep it at. And yeah, I mean a lot of these things kind of affect it, and those are the places that you find a lot of weight management therapies and trials and treatments focusing on.
Advertisement
John Horton:
Yeah. Now we've been using the term set point, which makes it seem like it's like one spot, like you're going to get on a scale every day and it's going to read one number. But the set point is kind of more of a range, right? Is there a little fluctuation in there?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
That is absolutely correct. So there is fluctuation on that. And a very important point is everyone is different. And so my personal belief, not to even go into the future, but it's a belief held by a lot of us who have been doing this for a while, is that the future of weight management is going to be personalized because of this problem or because of the finding. And that's why, like you said, it's a range. So the range is different for different people and different for different progressions of life.
One common question a lot of my patients ask me is, "Oh, Dr. C, how long will it take me to lose this weight?" And I tell them different people are different. People react to things differently, which will lead to personalized weight management treatment in the future. But it's also important that maybe if you're a different sex, it's going to be different.
So one of the places that I find in my patients, and I would say about 70% of my patients tend to be cis females, and it is mainly things like menopause, things like pregnancy. Those shift our set point quite a bit. In my males, it's usually puberty. And then as they get older, they have something called sarcopenic obesity. So different people are different. And even within the genders, we have variations of the set point.
Advertisement
And that's why, to your point, it usually ends up being a range rather than being a single set point. I know that at the Cleveland Clinic, we are currently looking to explore this further with a large cohort of patients. And hopefully once that information comes out, we will have a much better idea of what this means, the set point means, during the progression of someone's life.
John Horton:
Yeah. I know. I always feel like I have about a five-pound range that I kind of swing back and forth in, but you never go much outside at either end. You just kind of stay within there.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah, but at different stages of your life, right?
John Horton:
Right. My set point has moved over the years too. Talk about that a little bit as we go on.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Right. Yeah. So yeah. And that's exactly what it is. I mean, of course, a few pounds here and there is water weight also, but like you said, within certain passages of your life, you set those new set points. And yeah, I mean, that's what we see in everyone. And I always try to find a reason to make use of that information. And in my opinion, that information is going to lead to personalized weight management or obesity management for everyone, including at different stages of their life.
Advertisement
John Horton:
Yeah. Now, weight management is such a complex issue, which is why it's always fascinating having you on, because I feel like we have great discussions. And when we're talking about set point, then I feel like there are a lot of complexities that go into where that number ends up. And let's go through some of the things that might affect where your weight lands. You had mentioned hormones are one of the big things. What else do we have that's going to get that number at that certain spot?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah, like I said, I mean major life events. So puberty's a major life event in us, and puberty is one I think that we've seen affects a set point. Like I said, in my cis females, pregnancy, menopause. There's a large study that came out of New York which actually showed that there is weight gain associated with menopause, as well as an increase in visceral obesity. Like we talked about, the hormones that we talk about are not maybe even some of the hormones that people know about, unless you're in the field of weight management. There are these hormones like NPY and PPY, which actually affects the way we eat. And I'm not going to go into the weeds about what that means. So there's a lot of things that affect it, plus the regular day-to-day things that we go through.
So the other things that affect set points, just something as simply as translocation. So I know you guys are talking about moving. So going to Philadelphia. Let's say you were living in Philadelphia versus you were living somewhere in the south where culturally the food would tend to be more fattening. So those kind of things also play a role, things like moving. I have a lot of patients who say, "I gained weight when I moved to Ohio as opposed to when I lived in California."
I mean, these are all things that is part of our life, that people move because that's a change in their life that obviously made a betterment in their life and that's why they made the move. But there are downstream reasons where that can affect your weight. So these are things that a lot of people don't think about because of the focus that they have that it's kind of almost like a moral failing, I'm gaining weight.
But there are all these things that happened in our life that also play a role, socioeconomic factors. We can talk about food deserts. Food deserts, where you live in an area where you only have access to maybe very high calorie foods. If you live in a more rural area and you can't get to, let's say, a grocery where you have access to more healthy food. I mean, all these things kind of play a role in our set point.
John Horton:
Very complicated. There's all these factors going in. So obviously environment is really big, your access to food, the area that you live in, depending on the food there, physical activity. I mean, there's certain spots, if you're more active, your set point might be at a different spot. I'd imagine stress-
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
And then genetics, right? Genetics.
John Horton:
Oh yeah, genetics are huge.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Family members.
John Horton:
Would that set you at a certain spot?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah, absolutely. So one of the things we mentioned, I had a patient actually the other day where we have different body types also. So there's the Android or the Apple body type, which is what a lot of males have, where the weight is usually on top. And then females, usually cis females tend to have the gynoid or the pear-shaped body type where their fat tissue tends to accumulate hips and below.
And I mean there, there's a clear correlation that we've seen in other females in the family. So there's obviously a genetic predisposition to fat deposition. And I bring this up because a lot of times people think that having fat tissue hips and below doesn't really cause much of an issue or what they call healthy obesity, but that's not the case also because we know that you can still have things like pain.
But yeah, there's, I mean, all these things that really correlate into weight and the set point. And that's why we make it a point to say that weight is multifactorial, but that set point is multifactorial. And even though there are certain things that everyone might go through, like menopause, and if you decide to get pregnant, pregnancy, but then there's so many other things that kind of affect our set point as our lives progress that tends to be more personalized to everyone.
John Horton:
Yeah. And that's where I think you get into things like stress, sleep quality, like you said, physical activity, medications you might be on. All of those can have an effect on where your weight settles.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
100%. And so that is, again, going back to that multifactorial nature. Like you said, our patients who take psychiatric medications, we know that there's psychiatric medication-induced weight gain, so we know those can play a big role. And this is some other thing that's being closely looked at right now. And then also mental health is very closely tied to weight loss, so it has a large effect on weight management and that set point.
And because sometimes people are on those medications where I can't tell them get off the medication so we can lose weight because I need them in the right frame of mind to actually tackle the weight loss. So then we find alternative ways to move the set point on those patients. I have about 25% of my patients who unfortunately gained weight because they had traumatic experience, usually it's something like sexual abuse as a kid. And so those kind of things affect it. I have patients with eating disorders who their set point gets affected. And these are large proportion of patients that have this effect. So I guess what I'm trying to mainly point out to answer this question is the set point has so many things that goes into it that, again, it's very personalized, but also it's places that give opportunities for people to help patients and treat this.
John Horton:
Yeah. Is there even, I guess, early life experiences, can that play a role? I mean, we talk so much now, I feel like, about childhood obesity, and these patterns that you establish when you're a kid. Does that even kind of translate and kind of pop up then later as you're an adult, and your body's just going, hey, this is the weight where I should be at?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah. No, that's a great question. I don't know if you remember, but we did a podcast a couple of years ago, and I told you that Harvard did that study where they found when a baby's in the mother's stomach, the baby drinks more amniotic fluid when it's sweeter because it hits that hypothalamus to calm the [inaudible 00:15:09.
John Horton:
Yes, that was one of the most wild things to think about, how that kind of translates through.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
So that is a human being who is trained even before being born, that when they're stressed out that they want to go for sweets and carbs. So there's a lot of work also being done about, like I said, the different ways of how people got obese. So what we call obesity phenotypes. The studies are still going on with that, but there's all this work that we can kind of look at right from the start, from a young age, even before being born, to see why people tend to get their set point, because that's what we're talking about here, get their set point affected right from the start.
So yeah, I mean, again, like I said, something I always tell my patients, which even is not related to weight maybe, is we are all built from our experiences. So everything we deal with is from an experience we've had of dealing with it in the past. So yeah, I mean, there is definitely a correlation between our neural pathways, hedonic pathways, to affect the weight that probably comes from even from before we are born.
John Horton:
All right. Well, let me ask you this, and break down everything we just talked about, the complexity of weight management and where that all goes. And I feel like there's this debate you hear as to whether your weight is determined by biology or whether it's behavior, or the roles they both play. Is one of them doing a little more, or is it they're both kind of involved, and it's just a knot that's a little too complicated to untangle?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
It's both. OK. It's both because I mean the pathways show, and the GLP-1s, I mean, if you really want to talk about the GLP-1s, the thing that people should learn from the GLP-1s more than anything else is the fact that weight is not just about diet and exercise, which means environment, and it's not just about genetics. It's actually a combination of everything. Because now you're having people who haven't lost weight in 30, 40 years. And believe me, almost all of them have tried in the past, and almost all of them have had success in the past. I have patients who tell me, "You know what, Dr. C?" One of my very common questions is what's the most amount of weight you've lost? And almost everyone has lost a bunch of weight and gained it back.
And now these patients are on GLP-1s and that GLP-1 is helping them deal with the hormonal part and they're losing weight. But remember, it has a two-pronged approach. It also works on the brain, on the hedonic pathway. So the answer to all of this is it's not just biology or behavior, it's everything. And that is how we can say that it's a multifactorial disease, and that is how we have seen it in all the other multifactorial diseases, that includes sleep apnea and diabetes and everything else.
John Horton:
OK. So all these things, all these different factors go into setting our set point, and then it seems like once your body decides this is the number, this is where we're going to stay, it does things to protect that. How does your body put its thumb on the scale or whatever to keep you at a certain spot and make sure you don't vary?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah, so that's the concept of homeostasis, right? So homeostasis is balance. Homeostasis is a fancy word for balance. So when your body gets to a different set point, like I said, when you suddenly try to drop weight really fast, and we've seen this, then your body is like, you know what? Man, this person's really losing a bunch of weight. I need to get them back to where they were before. And right, that is exactly right.
And so I mean, I guess part of it is you can extrapolate that, as our life goes on, we are supposed to gain weight, but we know that gaining the weight has a lot of deleterious effects, visceral obesity, and the heart disease, diabetes, all the cardiometabolic issues. And then obviously pain. As we get older, we lose balance, all of that. But your body is like, hey, but this is what's supposed to happen as your life progresses.
So the reason we do all the interventions that we do is to try to improve your quality of life, mitigate those issues, but your body's always going to try to fight that. And that's where the concept of set point, or the set range like we talked about, comes in. And then your body releases hormones, peptides, works on your neural pathways, in your hedonic pathways in your brain to make sure that it tries to keep it at that level that it thinks that we should be having.
John Horton:
Yeah. I mean, when you look at it, I mean, it seems diabolical how your body works against you when you're trying to drop weight. And I was reading up on this, I saw where it will slow your metabolism down, so you're just not burning calories as fast. It'll lower your energy level so you don't feel like exercising as much, increase those cravings. All of a sudden that cupcake looks a little better than maybe what it did the week before. Just all of these things that your body is doing, unbeknownst to you, that's kind of working against your ability to drop pounds.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
That is correct. So a lot of my patients will say, "You know what, Dr. C, I skip breakfast or lunch." This is very common in healthcare workers. We tend to skip breakfast or lunch because we are rushing somewhere. And then they're like, "You know what? So I then eat a large meal at night." Because your body's going to ask you for those calories, or it's going to ask you to snack into the night. And what it does is your body is like, you know what? The whole day this person didn't eat. Now they're eating these calories at night, so I'm going to hold onto these calories by slowing down their metabolism. So there's even this kind of what we call the circadian rhythm of eating that sometimes goes against us if your body decides we are going to hold onto certain foods.
And then the other thing is, in terms of just holding on to the calories during wintertime, holding onto the calories if you're less active. We know when we are more active, we tend to burn more calories, so then your body's able to use those calories. I mean, all these things are kind of correlated to make sure that the body basically gets what it wants to. That's where, I mean, the training always comes in. That's where seeing a dietitian, seeing the trainers, I mean having this multimodal approach comes in because your body's trying all these different things to keep its set point. So you have to try all these different things to see how we can get around it.
John Horton:
I'm glad you mentioned weather. And I got to be honest, I have always felt like I have a weight that I'll hang around during summer and a weight I hang around when the snow starts flying up here. And I always say it's my body just getting a little insulation on it, but is there some truth to that? Your body kind of senses what's going on and it says, hey man, you need a little more, I guess, insulation around you.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
I mean, truthfully, John, I think the studies might be out on that, but the truth of the matter is there does seem to be a correlation with weather and weight. I don't want to speak, and somebody tells me, "Oh, there's no randomized controlled trial on it," and that's probably true. But yeah, no, we've seen this.
And I'll give you an example. As you know, I'm from Sri Lanka. So weight outside North America is very important to me also, especially in Asia. And in Asia and the Middle East, the concept of visceral obesity is actually even more important than here in North America because people from the Middle East and Asia tend to not be heavier in terms of the scale, subcutaneous fat, but they tend to have a lot more visceral fat, which is a lot more metabolic fat, which is around their heart and their liver. And that's why there's a lot of heart disease and liver disease outside of North America, in places like Asia and the Middle East.
And they do believe that it's related to the fact that those countries are closer to the equator. So if you're living closer to the equator, you tend to sweat more. So you don't have as much subcutaneous fat and don't look as heavy as maybe people who live in North America. However, those people tend to have a lot more fat tissue inside them around the heart and the liver, so they have a lot more metabolic disease than actually, believe it or not, the Western world where you would expect the Western diet to cause it more.
And so there is a correlation there with the weather and weight. And again, like I said, there's so much research that needs to be done in this field even now, that I think we're going to find things are going to be a lot more different in the future and things will be very, very personalized, like I said, between people, between different nations. I mean, I think different continents. I think this is going to be something that they'll definitely look into in the future.
John Horton:
Yeah. Well, I'm glad to hear that the weather might be a factor there. That makes way more sense to me than blaming all the Christmas cookies I put down. I mean, that couldn't possibly be the reason I put on a few extra pounds. But that's a whole other discussion, I guess. So I feel like our whole discussion has led us to this point and really the big central question, which is can we change our weight set point? And if so, how does that process happen?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
I think we can manage weight set point. And the way you can do it is obviously using a multimodal approach. So diet, exercise, medications, endoscopic procedures, bariatric surgeries for people who might be a lot further away from their set point. So just like any other condition, I think we can manage our set point. I always tell my patients, medicine means we are managing things.
Fortunately or unfortunately, at the end, we all die. We can't stop that. We can't stop the game, but we can delay the game. And when we delay the game, we want to make sure that people have a good quality of life the longer they live, and keep people healthy. I mean, that is the Hippocratic Oath that we all took to help people and not hurt people.
And I think the set point is going to show that, even in weight management, that this is not an aesthetic thing. This is a chronic condition, weight management, and it needs to be managed as such. And I think the set point will be the one that will actually show that more than anything else, that as our bodies go up in weight or as our life progresses, that we can manage it just like we manage all the other chronic diseases.
John Horton:
Yeah. So with resetting it, because I got to say, I was looking at my life as I was kind of prepping for this podcast, and I was always around the same weight. And you look at where you were at high school or whatever. I went to college, and I enjoyed college. And the combo of beer, late night pizza, and a whole bunch of other unhealthy food, I packed on some pounds.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Which is a fantastic college experience and you needed [inaudible 00:26:35].
John Horton:
Well, it was. I had a really good time and it showed. People talk about a freshman 20, I overachieved by a lot. But then I felt like I kind of hung around at a weight, I was a good 210 for a while. I'm 6'3", bigger guy, just felt like this is who I am. And my weight stayed there. Like you said, that set point was kind of there.
Then started looking at things, felt like, hey, I need to get a little healthier here. I started running. And I remember during that process, it was so hard to get the weight to go down. You felt like it went down a few pounds and it came back up and whatever. And eventually I kind of broke through, it felt like I broke through a wall.
And once I did that, I dropped pounds like crazy. And I went for a long stretch, I was down around 180, which my wife told me it was too skinny. She liked a little more cushion. I guess I was a little more cuddly. And then I stayed there for a while. And since then, I felt like it's adjusted up. Now I'm sitting around 190, and it's kind of been hanging in that range. But is that something that can happen where if you're going to change it, you've got to really do something drastic and force it below, and then your body will just recalibrate once you land at a new spot?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
So I think it's important for you to know that's your story. So why I'm telling you that is, let's say that you were a cis female, and you gained a bunch of weight in college, which we all did. I enjoyed college quite a bit too. And I went to college in Minnesota, so Minnesota and Wisconsin, we are known for liking our beer.
John Horton:
The cold weather too.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Right. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. I mean, that will be the excuse to have a bunch of beer. So let's say that they went through the same thing as you. And then let's say after college they decided to have kids. So they lost a bunch of weight, then they had kids, they gained the weight. Now it becomes a lot harder. With each kid, they put on more weight. So I think what you're telling is a typical story for some, but it might not be for everyone. But yeah, I mean, again, it goes back to that same point, that changing the set point and treating weight has to be a multimodal approach. For you, it was running, and then obviously I'm pretty sure you started eating healthier, and then-
John Horton:
A little bit, yeah.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
... the weight came up and down. I mean, it's the story definitely for some people and then not the story for others. If I was to give you the same example for myself, I moved from Sri Lanka to come to college here in the US in Minnesota in Winona State, shout out to my college. And when I moved countries, like I said, displacement, I moved from Sri Lanka where it's hot and we are always outside and all of that. I moved to Minnesota where it's cold.
And I used to lift a lot of weights back then. So I came here, and I was on the meal plan, and it was the six-egg omelets and all of that. And so I put on a bunch of weight. But because I was young and I was lifting a lot of weights, and I mean, you couldn't even see my neck back then. It's all traps. But then after you graduate from college, and obviously I went into medicine, and things obviously became a little bit more sedentary and all of that.
John Horton:
Long shifts, all that.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Correct. Night shifts, all the stuff we talk about with circadian rhythm of eating and everything. It was very hard, like you said. And so I gained a bunch of weight because I wasn't as active. I went to med school. I actually went to med school in the Caribbean in St. George's. Again, shout out to them.
John Horton:
You decided against the cold weather, huh? You were going to go a little more south.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
I wanted to go from cold to hot. Yeah. But I went to St. George's, and it was an island. So all we did was study and I started working out again. And actually I got to the lowest weight I've ever been even before I was living in Sri Lanka. So I started working out again. I actually ended up almost getting a six pack back then because all we would do on the island was study and work out. So and then after that, I moved to New York for training, and then the weight came again because, again, we are working night shifts.
So I think that example is also a common example. So a lot of people in medicine will tell that to you. Our weight fluctuates a lot depending on where we move to and all of that. So I mean, it's I think a testament to that is what we talked about there is environment because I'm moving from place to place, and different places, different circumstances.
But then as we get older, when the hormones and peptides and everything else takes into effect, like I said, with cis females, it's menopause. For men, for a lot of us, as we get older, we tend to lose a lot of muscle. We know this because we know, again, as an endocrinologist, I have to say that, as we get older, our testosterone level drops, so we lose muscle. Remember, muscle is heavier than fat tissue, so that shows a lower weight. So these are all these little nuances that people don't think about weight that gets affected, hormonal pathways, our neural pathways in our brains, our peptides. So all these things kind of play a role into the set point or the set range, like you mentioned. And I think what we're going to find out is everyone's different, and all of these things will play a role.
John Horton:
Yeah. So it seems like if you're going to change that set point, if you're looking to lose some weight and you want to do it, the key is you got to adopt sustainable long-term changes with how you're living and lifestyle and things like that. And you have to be patient because you're almost reteaching your body what weight it should be at. And it seems like the body's a slow learner when it comes to that.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Yeah. No, I think I would word it as changing the set point is pretty much like having a conversation with your body saying, hey, you're here right now, and I'm starting to get these aches and pains. I'm starting to get diabetes. So you and I need to come up with a plan. And of course that first plan is going and seeing a provider who is going to sit down and be able to, in an evidence-based way, provide you all the information with getting you to a dietitian and a trainer. And if you have eating disorders, endocrine psychologists, if it's medications, it's medications. If it's procedures, it's procedures. And having that conversation with your body saying, listen, I want to feel better and I want to work with you long term and have a good quality of life. And yeah, I think that's the best way to go about it. And so it should be sustainable, but it should be with all options available to that person.
John Horton:
Yeah. I've got to be honest, I've had that conversation with my body, and it's like talking to a toddler. So I keep hoping that it's going to come around, but it's always a struggle.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Your body's part of you, John. That conversation, just like with a toddler, I have a 2-year-old, I can tell you, we have these conversations every day. Sometimes I win, sometimes he wins.
John Horton:
Well, so with everything that we've talked about here, just to bring it on home with set point theory and weight loss in particular, because that's at the core of why we're even talking about this. If somebody is looking to lose weight, it sounds like the key is you have to get a solid plan in place. You have to be really diligent about following it and just keep going, keep pushing to reach your goals, and do it in a pretty well thought out manner. To you, because I know you work with this all the time, what's the best way to reach that goal, and maybe reset that set point and get to the weight that you want?
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
The best way is different for everyone. So the best way to reach your goal is actually to work with a team of people who can help you get to your goal. And the first thing is also deciding what that goal is. And the best way is, like I said, everything. So diet, exercise, being in the right mental health space, having good sleep, making sure you have access to the options that you have, whether it's medications or surgeries or procedures.
And the most important thing is don't be afraid to fail. Why? Because you are going to fail. And the best thing about failure is you learn from failure. You don't learn from just doing well all the time. So if you fail, you know something doesn't work, that means it's time to go to your provider and talk about something else.
And this applies to all chronic conditions. Like I said, I'm a board-certified endocrinologist as well as a weight loss doctor, and we have these same conversations about diabetes and high cholesterol and sleep apnea, and all these other things that we talk to our patients about. And it's OK to fail because this is not, you want to get out of that mindset of thinking it's just the aesthetic thing and think about how you want to not only change your set point to have weight loss, but sustain weight loss in the long run and have a good quality of life.
John Horton:
Yeah. So just keep plugging away at it. Don't give up, and eventually, hopefully you see some results.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
That is absolutely correct. So keep plugging away. Learn from anything where you find something's not working. Everyone is different in terms of whether it's diet, even diet and exercise, not just medications. Everyone is different when it comes to diet and exercise. Find what works for you and find what you can do long term. And if there are some mistakes on the way, learn from those mistakes and keep plugging away. You will know when you're doing well because you will just feel better.
John Horton:
All right. Well, Dr. C, this is why we love having you on. I always feel like when the conversation's over that I've learned a ton, and that's true with this discussion. And so thank you very much for coming in, and I can't wait to get you back on here.
Peminda Cabandugama, MD:
Thanks, John. Always looking forward to it. See you.
John Horton:
Set point theory is a good reminder that your weight is about much more than willpower. Biology, behavior, and environment all play a role. That helps explain why losing weight and keeping it off can be such a challenge. But lasting change is possible with realistic habits, patience, and the right support.
If weight is something you're struggling with, talk with your healthcare provider about a plan that works for you. If you liked what you heard today, please hit the subscribe button, and leave a comment to share your thoughts. Until next time, be well.
Recent Episodes
What Is Pulsed Electromagnetic Field (PEMF) Therapy?
Pulsed electromagnetic field (PEMF) therapy might sound space-age, but it’s a simple treatment that has become a popular option in wellness…
Do Our Eyes Grow as We Age?
It’s no secret we grow a lot between birth and adulthood – but do our eyes jump in size during that time, too? The answer is yes, with most…
Answering Questions About ADHD Medications
ADHD medications are widely used and often very effective – but they also come with questions. What do drugs like Ritalin and Adderall actua…
Never miss a moment - subscribe now.
Listen to the Health Essentials Podcast on your favorite streaming platform.
Other Podcasts You May Love
Beyond Leadership
Hosts Jim Pae and Elizabeth Pugel escort you through a network of thought leaders, sharing world-cla…
Beyond the Pages: CCJM Podcast
Beyond the Pages: CCJM Podcast takes the listener more in-depth into Cleveland Clinic Journal of Med…
Butts & Guts
A Cleveland Clinic podcast exploring your digestive and surgical health from end to end. You’ll lear…
Cancer Advances
A Cleveland Clinic podcast for medical professionals exploring the latest innovative research and cl…