Mom is One of First Patients to Receive New Heart Valve

Last football season, Carrie Hughes paused to rest and catch her breath nine times on the walk to Mountaineer Field — the gridiron home to her beloved West Virginia Mountaineers — as she and her husband, Jason, headed for their seats.

“I really had a hard time getting around,” said Carrie, age 42, and the mother of three children. “The fatigue, the shortness of breath. It just started getting worse and worse.”

Carrie was born with a unicuspid heart valve, a condition that constricts the flow of blood through the heart. Over time, the defective valve can narrow, even more, start to leak and become susceptible to calcification, resulting in the types of symptoms Carrie experienced. Her deteriorating condition made normal activities – working a full-time job, getting the kids to their activities, preparing meals – exhausting.

Carrie said that “every day was a challenge”— until she traveled to Cleveland in January 2018, become one of the first patients at Cleveland Clinic — and in the country — to receive a new type of aortic valve approved by the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) in 2017.

Carrie’s increased energy means more fun outings with her family.
Carrie’s increased energy means more fun outings with her family. (Courtesy: Carrie Hughes)

Performing the surgery was Lars Svensson, MD, PhD, Chairman of Cleveland Clinic’s Miller Family Heart & Vascular Institute; and a lead investigator in a multi-year trial of the valve that led to the new device’s FDA approval. The valve, known as a “bovine pericardial bioprosthesis,” is made from the tough tissue that surrounds a cow’s heart.

Dr. Svensson explained that the new biological valve is more durable than mechanical valves. “We hope it will fill a niche for younger patients like Carrie, who will benefit from a long-term valve,” he said.

While mechanical valves are effective, they tend to need replacement after about 20 years. Also, because they require the recipient to be on blood thinners, mechanical valves can be a less viable option for women planning to get pregnant, athletes, and other highly active people who may be susceptible to injury or other forms of blood loss.

“The new type of valve that Carrie received has been holding up very nicely in recipients,” Dr. Svensson said. “It will be a long time before we know how durable it will be in the long term, but it’s very promising so far.”

Carrie Hughes with her children.
Carrie Hughes with her children. (Courtesy: Carrie Hughes)

As soon as she awoke from the minimally invasive, 2.5-hour surgery in which Dr. Svensson used a keyhole-sized incision, Carrie felt revitalized. Within days, shortness of breath and fatigue were no longer issues, and the numbness she regularly felt in her limbs was gone. “I could tell a big difference right away,” she noted. “Now, I feel so much better and I can keep up with the kids.”

And Carrie, who lives in Princeton, West Virginia, is eagerly awaiting football season and a return trip to Morgantown to root for the Mountaineers.

“I think going back to the stadium will be much easier with my new-found stamina,” she said. “I’m ready to start a new chapter.”

Related Institutes: Heart, Vascular & Thoracic Institute (Miller Family)
Patient Stories

Patient Stories

Judy Garafalo before (left) and after (right) her weight loss

Patient Loses Weight, Gains New Sense of Well-Being

May 27, 2025

“I surprised myself. I didn’t think I could do it. I surprised myself. I've made lifestyle changes that I plan to maintain the rest of my life.”

Read Story
Alfin Jeyaseelan working out at a weight machine.

Too Young, Too Strong for a Stroke? How a 25-Year-Old Athlete Survived the Unthinkable

May 20, 2025

“That was truly nothing short of a miracle. Cleveland Clinic was amazing. The neuro team are a bunch of rock stars.”
Read Story
Lexi experienced a stroke when she was 18 years old.

Teen Finds New Appreciation For Life After Surviving a Stroke

May 14, 2025

“After my stroke, I realized you can’t take what you have for granted.”
Read Story
Back to Top