Surgical & Minimally Invasive Brain Tumor Treatment Options
Online Health Chat with Dr. Valerio
May 15, 2012
Cleveland_Clinic_Host: Every year in the United States, more than 300,000 people are diagnosed with a brain tumor, either primary or metastasized. Primary brain tumors are those that arise within the brain itself, unlike metastatic tumors that travel to the brain from cancer that has formed in another part of the body. Today’s medical advancements now offer state-of-the-art surgical treatment options, including many minimally invasive techniques, to provide brain tumor patients with new hope for managing their disease.
Dr. Jose Valerio is a board certified neurosurgeon who treats patients at Cleveland Clinic Florida (Weston, FL) and at Cleveland Clinic main campus (Cleveland, OH). Specializing in the neurosurgical management of adult benign and malignant tumors of the brain and spinal cord, Dr. Valerio’s interests also include Gamma Knife cranial radiosurgery, as well as research and clinical trials.
Dr. Valerio received his medical degree from Universidad Autonoma De Guadalajara Faculty of Medicine (Guadalajara, Mexico). He completed his neurosurgical residency at Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (Mexico City, Mexico). Dr. Valerio completed a research fellowship in Cerebrovascular and Physiology Research and Stroke at Case Western Reserve University (Cleveland, OH) and also completed two Neurosurgical Oncology Fellowships and one complex spine fellowship at Cleveland Clinic. He obtained the American Brain Tumor Young Investigator award and multiple brain tumor research fellow awards at Cleveland Clinic in Ohio. Dr. Valerio is the president of the Latin American Chapter of the Young Neurosurgeons group of the Federation of Latin American Neurosurgical Societies (Federación Latinoamericana de Sociedades de Neurocirugía, or FLANC). He is part of the international executive committee of the tumor section in AANS/CNS and secretary for the tumor section of FLANC.
To make an appointment with Dr. Valerio at Cleveland Clinic Florida, please call 877.463.2010. To make an appointment with any of the Rose Ella Burkhardt Brain Tumor Center physicians at Cleveland Clinic Main Campus, please call 866.588.2264. You can also visit us online at clevelandclinic.org/braintumor.
Cleveland_Clinic_Host: Welcome to our Online Health Chat with Cleveland Clinic specialist Dr. Jose Valerio. We are thrilled to have him here today for this chat. Let’s begin with some of your questions.
General Treatment Questions
KDelphi: I have a meningioma that my physician says should be left alone, except for "checking" an MRI every 6 months. How do I live with that? Thanks.
Dr__Valerio: We treat the individual patient, not pictures (MRIs). If the patient has an incidental finding that appears to be a meningioma, and if is not producing symptoms, the recommended treatment is actually observation. An MRI every 3, 6, and 12 months is the common practice we follow. We continue to observe the tumor every year. If the tumor starts to produce symptoms and is growing, the tumor should be removed OR treated with radiosurgery.
boom_boom: Are primary brain tumors diagnosed or treated differently than metastasized brain tumors?
Dr__Valerio: Primary brain tumors are treated differently based on the diagnosis. Brain tumors can be extra-axial tumors (outside of the brain), and there are tumors that are inside of the brain. Based on the diagnosis, size, location, etc., we can decide if we are going to do tumor resection or not.
In metastasis, it is very important to know if the cyst is under control. Based on that, we can decide to treat the metastasis with radiosurgery, radiation therapy, or surgical resection. Most of the time, metastases smaller than 2.5cm are treated with radiosurgery; lesions bigger than this are treated surgically.
bdy65: If you are diagnosed with a brain tumor, what are the possible treatment options?
Dr__Valerio: Observation, minimally invasive surgical approaches, radiation, and chemotherapy. You can learn more about treatment options on our website clevelandclinic.org/braintumor.
grant3: Can I treat my metastasized brain tumor while I am still receiving chemo/radiation for my primary cancer?
Dr__Valerio: Yes, but this all depends upon what kind of chemotherapy you are receiving. Some types of chemotherapy need to be stopped for at least 2 weeks to a month before the brain tumor treatment can commence due to the risk of bleeding.
rosebloom: Are there different treatment options for an adult diagnosed with a brain tumor, versus a child diagnosed with a brain tumor?
Dr__Valerio: Most pediatric brain tumors are different than adult brain tumors. There are different ways to treat different tumors depending on the diagnosis. It is difficult to answer this question, but the frequency and the diagnosis of the types of brain tumors in children are very different than the brain tumors in adults.
i_want: How long will I have to wait after having tumor resection surgery before I can begin subsequent radiation or chemotherapy to ensure my brain tumor is thoroughly treated?
Dr__Valerio: Once we do surgery, we try to do radiation as soon as possible (within about three weeks). Next, we will do radiation in conjunction with chemotherapy for 6 weeks. This is then stopped for one month, and we follow up with an MRI. Chemotherapy is resumed for 6 to 12 months.
keep_moving: What are the most effective non-surgical treatment options available for treating a brain tumor?
Dr__Valerio: This depends on the type of brain tumor. One option is treatment with radiosurgery; another one could be chemotherapy. Additionally, there are some tumors that can go untreated and just need to be observed.
live_free: What is the average recovery time for having a brain tumor removed with surgery?
Dr__Valerio: If everything goes well, and there are no complications from the surgery, patients are discharged from the hospital three days after surgery. The healing process for the skin incision can take ten days.
laura628: I see Accutane being prescribed for some brain tumor patients. How is that drug helpful for brain tumors?
Dr__Valerio: Accutane® (isotretinoin) is not a standard of care treatment, but it is being used in a clinical trial. It is medication that has shown a strategic benefit when combined with Temodar® (temozolomide), another chemotherapy agent. There is no magic bullet to treat brain cancer, but when patients do not respond well to this treatment, we can look to the clinical trials like those for Accutane.
laura628: I have heard that Avastin® (bevacizumab) is considered the "last chance" drug when all else fails. Is this true, or is Avastin being used also for newly diagnosed glioblastoma?
Dr__Valerio: Avastin is the second FDA-approved drug for glioblastomas. The standard of care is the Stupp protocol that includes radiation and chemotherapy with Temodar. When this standard of care fails, Avastin is one option or any other clinical trial that is available for glioblastomas. Again, there is no "magic bullet" for brain cancer, but there are some treatments and clinical trials out in the market that can increase the quality of life of the patients in order to prolong the window of survival and open opportunities for treatment.
jenl75: I know that Cleveland Clinic is very active in offering a number of clinical trials for the treatment of high-grade glioblastomas. I am currently in consideration for the Tocagen trials, but is there anything you know of that I should also be considering?
Dr__Valerio: Cleveland Clinic does use the NeuroBlate® or AutoLITT® system. This is a minimally invasive surgical approach in which we use a laser probe that goes directly to the tumor. We then basically burn the malignant cells with the laser with very precise accuracy. For more information about this procedure you can visit clevelandclinic.org/autolitt.
There is also a clinical trial using Gamma Knife radiosurgery and Avastin. Another clinical trial is with the combination of Temador and Avastin. There is a series of new clinical trials that our neurosurgery oncologists provide. You can find more information on clevelandclinic.org/braintumorclinicaltrials.
oh_yeah: I have heard of a number of radiosurgery options for treating brain tumors. What is the difference between CyberKnife®, Novalis®, Gamma Knife®, etc.?
Dr__Valerio: Gamma Knife is a stereotactic radiosurgery treatment where the target of radiation is determined based on Cartesian coordinates (a way of pinpointing an exact location within a three dimensional space).With Gamma Knife, the patient’s head is placed in a frame that is attached by pins. Novalis and Cyber Knife procedures are different in that a linear accelerator is used to target treatment location. They use a mesh fusion to immobilize the patient because they do not use a head frame.
cmcal12: What risks are associated with radiosurgery?
Dr__Valerio: Risks all depend upon where the lesion is located in the brain. The most important thing about radiosurgery is being able to receive this treatment in a certified facility that has a team of medical physicists, a radiation oncologist, and a neurosurgeon. It is necessary to have the three specialists to make this treatment more consistent, safe, and accurate.
readingr: What types of brain tumors can the Gamma Knife treat?
Dr__Valerio: Most types of brain tumors can be treated using Gamma Knife. The Radiation Oncology Group, an association that regulates the radiation treatment, has mentioned there is a reduction in the use of radiosurgery in gliomas, but most of the other tumors can use Gamma Knife as one of the tools of treatment as a primary therapy or as a secondary therapy.
Glioblastomas and Other Cancers
laura628: Is there a limit on the number of times a glioblastoma patient can receive proton therapy?
Dr__Valerio: For glioblastoma, proton therapy is not the first treatment option. For a glioblastoma, the standard of care is maximum surgical resection followed by chemo/radiation.
js121499: How common is the PTEN mutation found in gliomas. My 12-year-old had a low-grade cerebellar tumor removed. Also, I have heard some speculation that this mutation has been found in patients with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM). If so, how common is it?
Dr__Valerio: PTEN mutation occurs in about 20% of glioblastomas, but is rare in low-grade gliomas. The presence of this mutation makes us aware that we must closely follow up to confirm that it does not turn into a high-grade glioblastoma.
js121499: Thank you, Dr Valerio. Does the PTEN mutation affect how a person responds to treatment, or it is more of a recurrence issue due to the overgrowth issue?
Dr__Valerio: PTEN mutation in low-grade gliomas is excessively rare. There are no clinical trials that have been focused in a prognostic factor for these conditions.
As for the presence of this mutation in high-grade gliomas, we must evaluate more frequently for the possibility of recurrence or transformation from low-grade to high-grade. There is also not a lot of data to see how this affects treatment.
What we have to understand is that no matter what kind of mutation the tumor has, we need to follow the standard of care. The standard of care for high-grade gliomas is radiation and chemotherapy, dependent upon on what kind of tumor the patient has.
If the tumor is a low-grade glioma, there are prognostic factors that can predict the transformation to high-grade. These factors are: the type of tumor (astrocytoma), the size of the tumor (larger than 4 cm), the age of the patient (if they are older than 50 years old), and the location (if it is in an eloquent area or not.) These four predictive factors have been described as having the potential to advance to high-grade, and these are considered to be more prognostic than any mutation.
laber914: I was diagnosed with a tumor on my pituitary. Right now the doctor is doing an MRI once a year to see if it grows. I am really worried. I have been getting headaches and wanted to know if this is a normal follow up on a pituitary tumor.
Dr__Valerio: The follow-up care will be different in every case, but in general, yes. There is a 50% chance of a relationship between headaches secondary to pituitary tumors. For this reason, headache symptoms are not necessarily an indication for tumor resection (surgery). Tumor resection will not guarantee that headaches will go away.
The indication for pituitary resection is that the tumor is growing, that the tumor is producing a visual impairment, or that the tumor becomes hormonal functional, meaning that it is producing a high volume of any hormone.
ssstephanian: What is the best current treatment available for skull base tumors like chordoma?
Dr__Valerio: Chordoma of the clivus is a difficult lesion to treat. Sometimes you are required to do a surgical resection when the tumor is producing too much mass and the size of the mass compresses the brain stem. There is adjunct therapy (in addition to) for the treatment known as Gamma Knife® radiosurgery or proton beam therapy.
Proton beam therapy is available in limited cities in the United States in relation to Gamma Knife, which you can find commonly in many local cancer centers. There is enough data that shows radiosurgery is effective for chordomas and tumor control
Cleveland_Clinic_Host: I'm sorry to say that our time with Cleveland Clinic specialist Dr. Jose Valerio is now over. Thank you, Dr. Valerio, for taking the time to answer our questions today about surgical and minimally invasive brain tumor treatment options.
Dr__Valerio: Thank you very much for your questions.
To make an appointment with Dr. Valerio at Cleveland Clinic Florida, please call 877.463.2010, or with any of the Rose Ella Burkhardt Brain Tumor Center physicians at Cleveland Clinic Main Campus, please call 866.588.2264. You can also visit us online at clevelandclinic.org/braintumor.
A remote second opinion may also be requested from Cleveland Clinic through the secure eCleveland Clinic MyConsult Web site. To request a remote second opinion, visit eclevelandclinic.org/myConsult
If you need more information, click here to contact us, chat online or call the Center for Consumer Health Information at 216.444.3771 or toll-free at 800.223.2272 ext. 43771 to speak with a Health Educator. We would be happy to help you. Let us know if you want us to let you know about future web chat events!
Some participants have asked about upcoming web chat topics. If you would like to suggest topics, please use our contact link clevelandclinic.org/webcontact.
This information is provided by Cleveland Clinic as a convenience service only and is not intended to replace the medical advice of your doctor or health care provider. Please consult your health care provider for advice about a specific medical condition. Please remember that this information, in the absence of a visit with a health care professional, must be considered as an educational service only and is not designed to replace a physician's independent judgment about the appropriateness or risks of a procedure for a given patient. The views and opinions expressed by an individual in this forum are not necessarily the views of the Cleveland Clinic institution or other Cleveland Clinic physicians. ©Copyright 1995-2012 The Cleveland Clinic Foundation. All rights reserved.